NETHERLANDSJOURNALOF AQUATICECOLOGY30(1) 41-48 (1996)
A SEMINAL STUDY OF THE DYNAMICS
OF A MUDSKIPPER (PERIOPHTHALMUSPAPILIO)POPULATION
IN THE CROSSRIVER, NIGERIA*
LAWRENCE ETIM, THOMAS BREY and WOLF ARNTZ
KEYWORDS: Population dynamics; mudskipper; Periophthalmus papilio; Cross River; Nigeria.
ABSTRACT
A seminal study was conducted in which the population dynamics (growth, mortality and recruitment)
of the mudskipper (Periophthalmus papilio) in the Cross River, Nigeria, was elucidated for the first time
using length frequency data and the ELEFAN software. The allometric relationship was: Weight =
O.012(Length) 2.94o, n = 415, r 2 = 0.939, P <0.0005. The seasonalized Von Bertalanffy growth parameters
were Loo = 19.39 cm, K = 0.51 y - l , C = 0.3, and WP = 0.4. The instantaneous total mortality coefficient
Z was 2.208 y-1 while the instantaneous natural mortality coefficient was 1.341 y-l. The instantaneous
fishing mortality coefficient of 0.867 y--1 yielded the expectedly low exploitation rate E of 0.393. Our estimate
shows that the species could reach an average maximum life span of about 6 years in the Cross River system. These results are used in quantitative elucidation of the state of exploitation of the population and will
serve as input for the proper and scientific management of the fish resource.
and is invariably the best known example of resident
intertidal fish. It is a traditional delicacy of some
riverine ethnic groups in South Eastern Nigeria. According to CLAYTON(1993) mudskipper is also eaten
in China, Taiwan, and in India, where it provides an
alternative fishery during the monsoon. In Taiwan, it
is extensively cultured and in Malaysia aphrodisiac
values are attributed to its raw flesh. It is utilized
by some Nigerian artisanal fishermen as baits in
exploiting other commercially important species.
In this study, the population dynamics (growth,
mortality, recruitment) of the mudskipper Periophthalmus papilio in the Cross River system were
investigated in order to quantify the basic fishery
parameters which are necessary as input in the
quantitative elucidation of the state of exploitation
of the population. Proper understanding of the
latter is necessary for the scientific management of
stock.
INTRODUCTION
The mudskipper or mudhopper is an extremely euryhaline teleost fish whose habitats range
from muddy intertidal banks of rivers through
brackish to oceanic environments. There is acute
paucity of scientific research on this amphibious
fish. For example, literature search using ASFA
reveals that between 1978 and 1995 only 54
papers were published on mudskipppers worldwide. Out of this, only three (BERTI et aL, 1992;
1994; COLOMBINIet aL, 1995) were done in Africa.
The dearth of studies on this ammoniotelic
fish especially in Africa may well be due to the
fact that it is not a widely accepted food fish.
Consequently, mudskipper fishery is almost inexistent or entirely subsistent. However, the mudskippper is of both ecological and economic importance. It occupies a unique niche in its habitat
* Alfred Wegener Institute Contribution nr. 1090.
41
42
ETIM,BREYand ARNTZ
MATERIAL AND METHODS
posed by PAULY and GASCHUIZ (1979) and later
modified by SOMERS(1988) takes the form
From February to June 1994, samples of P.
papilio were obtained at monthly intervals from the
Cross River at the Esuk Nsidung, Calabar (8 ~ 3" E,
4 ~ 55" N) through the help of artisanal fishermen.
Rainfall has the most profound effect on the hydrology and limnology of the river system. During the
rains an enormous amount of run-off water with
heavy load of debris is brought into the river system
causing a tremendous rise in the level of the water.
The salinity ranges between 4.4%0 in the rainy season and 21%o in the dry season. Spatial and vertical
variation in temperature is negligible but seasonal
variation has been recorded. A peak temperature of
about 33.3~ is observed in April while a minimum
of about 26% is observed in July. The mean value
of transparency is 0.57 m, of pH 6.8, of nitrate 1.02
mg 1-1, of phosphate 0.017 mg 1-1, and of silicate
5.9 mg 1-1. The phosphate values for the bottom and
surface are the same. For silicate, the bottom values
are higher than the surface values.
The fish was caught by means of a simple trap
device. A cylindrical hole of about 15 to 20 cm deep
is dug in the ground and covered with a plant leaf
on which a bait is placed. When the mudskipper
jumps on the leaf for the bait, the leaf gives way
under the weight of the mudskipper and it falls
into the pit from where it cannot escape. The total
length and total weight of each specimen were
measured with callipers (to the nearest 0.1 cm) or a
balance (to the nearest 0.1g).
AIIometric relations
A power function of the form
Weight = a(Length) b
(1)
was fitted iteratively to the length-weight data
through the Simplex algorithm (PRESS et al., 1986)
employing the user-specified procedure available
on SYSTAT(1992). Here a and b are the intercept on
the y-axis and the slope of the regression line,
respectively.
Growth analysis
The ELEFAN software (BREYet aL, 1988; GAYANILO et al., 1989) was used for the analysis.
Growth in fishes is commonly described by the
VONBERTALANFFY(1938) growth function (VBGF)
Lt = Loo (1- e -k(t- to))
(2)
of which the seasonally oscillating version as pro-
Lt = Loo[ (1 - exp -(K(t - to)- CK/2~ ( sin 2~ (t- ts)
- sin 2~ ( t o - ts))].
(3)
Expression (3) was used to parametize individual
growth of P. papilio. Loo is the asymptotic length, K
the Von Bertalanffy growth coefficient, Lt the length
at age t, C the indicator of the intensity of growth
oscillations, t o the 'age' of the fish at zero length
(granted the fish had been growing according to the
VBGF) and t s the beginning of the sinusoidal growth
oscillation with respect to t = O. To facilitate biologically meaningful computation, t s was replaced by
WP (Winter Point) which is t s + 0.05. By definition
WP is the period of the year (expressed as a fraction
of the year) when growth is slowest.
To obtain a first estimate of Loo, the WETRERAL
(1986) method, as modified by PAULY (1986) was
used. It is a steady-state model and applies when
population mortality follows a single negative exponential model (see below) with a stable age
distribution. The method entails regressing L m - L'
against L' according to the linear regression
equation
L m - L' = a + bL'; Loo = a/-b
(4)
where L m is the mean length computed from L'
upward in the length frequency sample, while L' is
the limit of the first length class used. The sequentially arranged length frequency data set was
restructured to enable an objective definition (or
identification) of peaks which could be confidently
assumed to correspond to 'cohorts' (BREY et al.,
1988). Then, using the first estimate of Loo as a
seeded value, and a combination of various K
values, growth curves were fitted to the restructured data beginning from the base of each peak
and projecting backward and forward in time to
meet all other samples of the same set. The curve(s)
that passes through the highest number of peaks
and avoided the highest number of troughs yields
the best parameter estimate.
Mortality estimate
The size-converted catch curve (PAULY, 1983)
was used to estimate the total mortality coefficient Z
of the single negative exponential mortality model:
Nt = NOe-zt,
(5)
where NO is the initial number, and Nt is the number
Mudskipperpopulation dynamics
at time t. Z was computed from pooled size-frequency data with monthly samples N/size class converted to %N/size class. This conversion conferred
the desired effect of equal weight to each sample
(BREY eta/., 1988):
(Ni/6ti) = NOe-Zti,
(7)
Ni is the number of mudskippers in size class i, Lil
and Li2 are the upper and lower limits of the size
class i, t~ti is the time required to grow through this
size class and t i is the relative age of the mid-size of
class i as estimated from the inverse form of the
Von Bertalanffy equation
t i = In (1 - Lt /Loo)/K.
(8)
By plotting In (N i/Ati) against t i, a straight descending right arm was obtained and Z was computed
from the linear regression
In(%Ni/&ti) = a + bt i,
(9)
where Z = -b. The growth of any fish is not linear.
So the division of ON by At i in eq. (9) serves
to correct for the nonlinearity of the growth of
the mudskipper. In addition, Z was also estimated
from the mean length of the fish in the catch using
the BEVERTONand HOLT(1956) method
Z=[K(Loo-Lm)]/(Lm-L'),
the mudskipper. Since Z is equal to the sum of
the instantaneous natural mortality coefficient M
and instantaneous fishing mortality coefficient F,
the latter was then calculated from the relationship
F = Z - M; and the exploitation rate E was estimated
as F/Z.
(6)
hence
6t i = (-l/K)In(Loo - Li2/Loo - Lil )
43
Probability of capture
The probability of capture P of each size class i
was calculated from the ascendin0, left arm of the
length-converted catch curve following the method
of PAULY(1964). This entails dividing the numbers
actually sampled by the expected numbers (obtained by projecting backward the straight portion
of the catch curve) in each length class in the
ascending part of the catch curve. By plotting the
cumulative probability of capture against mid length
a resultant curve was obtained from which the
length at first capture Lc was taken as corresponding to the cumulative probability at 0.5 (50%).
Recruitment pattern
The procedure used here first corrects the
length frequency data for nonlinear fish growth,
then projects it back to a one-year time scale to
obtain a graphical representation of the recruitment
pattern (PAULY,1987).
Yield per recruit
The relative yield per recruit and biomass per
recruit were estimated from the model of BEVERTON
and HOLT ( 1966):
(Y/R)' = EUm {1 - (3U)/(l+m) + (3U2)/(1+2m)
(10)
where L m is the mean length of all fish which is
equal to or longer than L', the latter being the
smallest length fully represented in the length
frequency data. The coefficient of instantaneous
natural mortality M was estimated from two models,
viz: the empirical relationship proposed by PAULY
(1980):
- (U 3)/(1 +3m)},
(13)
where E = F/Z = the exploitation rate (Le. the
mortality of the mudskipper caused by the fishermen), U = 1 - Lc/Loo, which is the fraction of
growth to be completed by the mudskipper after
entry into the exploitation phase, and m = (1 E)/(M/K), which is equal to K/Z. The other parameters were already defined.
log M = -0.006 - 0.279 log Log
+ 0.654 log K + 0.463 log T,
(11)
where T is the mean annual environmental temperature in degrees Centigrade (here 30~ ), and
the model of TAYLOR(1960):
M = 2.9957/(t o + 2.9957/K),
(12)
where 2.9957/K is the estimator of longevity of
RESULTS
The length-weight regression (Fig. 1) was:
Weight = O.012(Length) 2.94o, n = 415, r2 =
0.939, P<O.O005. Estimated values of Log and
Z/K as obtained from the modified Wetheral plot
(Fig. 2) were 19.39 cm and 3.989, respectively.
The run of ELEFAN with Log = 19.39 cm as the
seeded value produced the seasonalized growth
44
ETIM, BREY and ARNTZ
60
f
50
-16
J
40
30
20
I
I
J
I0
~ ,j~r
I
5
0
0
9
Months
I
i0
I
15
LENGTH
Fig. 1. Length-weight relationship of Periophthalmus papilio in the
Cross River system. Weight (g) = 0.012 (Length in cm) TM, n =
415, r2 = 0.939, P < 0.0005.
curve depicted in Fig. 3 as superimposed on the
restructured length frequency histograms. The
curve is characterized by the following seasonalized
Von Bertalanffy parameters Loo = 19.39 cm, K =
0.51 y-l, C = 0.3, WP = 0.4. Incidentally, Loo values
from the modified Wetheral and ELEFAN methods
were the same. Up to four peaks could be identified
in this diagram (see Fig. 3, April sample) and they
are taken to correspond to separate cohorts.
The length-converted catch curve procedure
(Fig. 4) yielded an instantaneous total mortality
Fig. 3. Seasonalized Von Bertalanfly growth curve (parameter
values: Loo= 19.39cm, K=0.51 y - 1 C =0.3, and WP=0.4)
superimposed on the restructured length frequency histogram of
Periophthalmus papilio in the Cross River system. The black and
white bars are positive and negative deviations from the 'weighted'
moving average.
coefficient Z = 2.208 y-1 while a value of 2.283
y-1 was obtained from the mean length analysis.
The instantaneous fishing mortality rate and instantaneous natural mortality coefficient were 0.867
y-1 and 1.341 y-l, respectively, giving a current
exploitation rate E = 0.393. The analysis of probabilities of capture shows that the length at first
capture was 7.6 cm (Fig. 5).
We computed relative yield per recruit using
two different sets of assumptions and inputs. In
assuming knife edge selection (Fig. 6) we obtained
5-
24,8
0
0
0
0
/
9
Points
0
P o i n t s riot
II
. .
uSed
I
0
%4
0
0
!
m
0
0
3.0
o
I
,
,
,
,
4.s
o
oi
i6.s
Midlength
(cmJ
I
!
!
i
i
|
4.s
I
m.s
Cutoff Length
( L ) cm)
Fig. 2. Modified Wetheral plot for Periophthalmus papilio in the Cross River system. The arrow in the left graph indicates the first selected
point. The points used in the right graph are described by the equation Y = 3.89 - 0.201 X, r = 0.989. Estimated L~o = 19.39 cm, Z/K = 3.99.
Mudskipperpopulationdynamics
45
"1.0
~ e
~" 0.01110"
~ 1.05. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ii
3O
.<
o ~ 1 7 6 1 7 6
w
5"
Z
,<
0.5
c
..J
3~
84
o
RelotWeAge t (Years)
0-1
3I
O-I
Fig. 4. Length-converted catch curve for Periophtha/mus papilio
in the Cross River. Range of lengths 4.95 cm to 16.95 cm. Dots
indicate points included in the regression: Y = 10.9 - 2.208 X, r =
0.95, n = 7.
0-5
t-O
Exploitation
Rate
E
Fig. 6. Relative yield per recruit (Y'/R) and relative biomass per
recruit (B'/R) of Periophthalmus papilio as computed with the knife
edge selection procedure. The optimum exploitation rate (Emax) of
0.69 is indicated by the broken line. EO.1 = 0.6 and Eo.5 = 0.3.
1.0-
t,,,.
F
MI
O
3b.
0"5-
,.a
0-142................
-~
ll.O
0-071-
--0-5[
o
n
! I
0-0
4.55
/
i
10-5
Fig. 5. Probability of capture of Periophthalmus papilio as derived
from the length-converted catch curve. Broken line indicates mean
length at first capture (Lo.5), which is 7.6 cm. L0.25 = 6.7 cm. and
Lo.75= 8.5 cm.
the following summary statistics for the optimum
level of exploitation : Emax as 0.69, but using selection ogive or probability of selection procedure
(Fig. 7) a value of Emax = 0.52 was obtained. As
shown in Fig. 8 the recruitment pattern displayed
two peaks. The longevity or the average life span of
the species in the Cross River was about 5.9 years.
DISCUSSION
From the extant scientific literature, it is
clear that this is the first time in which the po-
0-0
01.1 L
~
i
I
0-5
Exploitation
i
Rate
b
~
1.0
E
Fig. 7. Relative yield per recruit (Y'/R) and relative biomass per
recruit (B'/R) of Periophthatmus papitio as computed with the probability selection procedure. The optimum exploitation rate of 0.52
is indicated by the broken line. EO.1 = 0.45 and EO.5 = 0.3.
pulation dynamics of any species of mudskippper
has been reported. Thus, our result, apart from
being seminal, will serve as a springboard for
further research in this field. The power function of
the type we used in equation 1 is usually fitted
to data through the least square procedure using
the following linearized version
log (Weight) = log a + b log(Length).
(14)
46
ET~M,BREYand ARNTZ
30.0-
E
I5-O-
n,,
k.
s
f
f
k-.,..--
One
Year
Fig. 8. Recruitment pattern of Periophthalmus papilla in the Cross River system.
According to SPRUGEL(1983) this kind of transformation introduces a systematic bias into the
calculation, which should be eliminated by multiplying with a correction factor (CF):
CF = exp (SEE2/2)
(15)
SEE = ~/[,T_,( log Yi- log y^ )2/(N_2) ]
(16)
and
SEE is the standard error of estimate, log Yi'S are
the log-transformed values of the dependent variable, log y^'s are the corresponding predicted
values from eq. (14). The SEE must be converted to
base e (by multiplying by 2.303) before being used
in eq. (15). The logarithmic correction factor is a
simple and straightforward statistical tool to remove
systematic bias. Although such error could be as
high as 10% (SPRUGEL, 1983), this procedure is
scarcely adopted by scientists. In our analysis, we
fitted the model iteratively to the data, consequently
the parameters were free of this kind of transformation-related bias. The resultant length-weight
model could explain up to 88.2% of the variation of
length on weight of the mudskipper.
To facilitate future comparisons of growth
performance of other populations, we will use the
PAULYand MUNRO(1984) equation
~' = log K + 2 log Loo
(17)
to quantify growth performance ~' as 2.28. Generally, ~' values are species specific parameters
and have been shown to be narrowly distributed
around a mean which is characteristic of the species, whether shellfish (VAKILY, 1992) or finfish
(MOREAU,1986 ).
Our data are limited to the five-month dry
season period because during the peak of the rains
the muddy intertidal portions of the river are permanently flooded and the mudskippers were not
found. Mudskippers have been described as one of
the most terrestrial of the amphibious fishes. P.
koelreuteri has been observed to carry out multiple
terrestrial excursions for feeding without a return to
water (SPONDER and LAUOER, 1981) but it is not
known how far or how long P. papilla could wander
landward. However, some species of mudskippers
do build complex burrows (CLAY-rOB,1993) and studies have shown that they are particularly capable of
existing in sustained hypoxic conditions in their
natural habitats (LOWet al., 1992).
From a study of otolith rings of Boleophthalmus dentatus (= B. dussumieri ) at the West
coast of the Indian continent, SON~ and GEORGE
(1986) showed that a 13.0 cm total length fish
is 2 years old. Our non-seasonalized Van Bertalanffy growth function (eq. (1)) yields a comparable value of 2.176 years for a 13.00 cm fish,
granted the value of t o is zero. Axiomatically, this
Mudskipper population dynamics
provides a good validation of the length-based ELEFAN procedure used in this analysis.
The K value generally expresses the rate at
which a species grows towards its asymptotic size,
which is the theoretical maximum size attainable by
the species in that particular habitat, given the
ecological peculiarities of the environment under
consideration. Our K value of 0.51 y-1 shows that
the species in the Cross River is relatively fast
growing. Our qualitative observation revealed that
there seems to be a gradation in maximum size of
the mudskipper with habitat. Thus the larger sized
individuals are common towards the oceanic environment, while the smaller sized ones are common in the riverine environments. It is not certain
whether this difference is due to differences in
fishing pressures on the different stocks or merely
to a consequence of ecological adaptation. Our
results show that the pressure on the fishery as
indicated by the exploitation rate of 0.35 is low
and quite below the predicted optimum of 0.69
based on knife edge selection, or 0.52 based on
assumption of probability selection. Within this
context, stepping up fishing mortality or bringing
down the size at first capture may lead to higher
yields for the fishermen without real danger to the
fishery. Moreover, in small tropical fisheries like
this the maximization of yield may require high F
values.
The mudskippers' extreme ability to manoeuvre
over the muddy environment, difficult of access
for man, implies that they are not easy to catch.
Although various catching techniques and devices
have been used, CLAYTON(1993) pointed out that
specimens caught by blowpipe, weighted hook and
air riffle are often not of use for further scientific
studies. Fish caught by traps, nets or lassos are
obviously more preferable. The probability of capture for the fishing method employed here shows
that the length at first capture is 7.6 cm and that
the probability of the device capturing a fish equal
47
to or greater than 10.5 cm in length is unity.
Although our computation puts the estimated maximum age of the species at about 6 years, yet our
restructured length - frequency diagram could only
account for four cohorts. The whereabouts of the
other two could probably be accounted for by selectivity of the gear.
The Chinese mudskipper P. cantonensis exhibits reproductive behaviour of nesting and courtship in the months of June to August (IKEBE and
OISHI, 1992) but nothing is reported about the
pattern of its recruitment. Conceptually, a recruitment pattern can be represented by a graph whose
peaks and troughs reflect the seasonality of recruitment to the stock in question. The overlapping
nature of the pattern (Fig. 8) implies a continuous
recruitment, while the two peaks denote that there
are two recruitment pulses in a year. If so, this is
different from the bivalve Egeria radiata (ETIM, 1993;
ETIMand BREY,1994) which spawns once a year in
the same river but similar to the croaker Pseudotolithus elongatus (ETIM et aL, 1994) which exhibits two recruitment peaks in a year, also in the
Cross River. For the recruitment pattern to indicate
the exact time of spawning, t o must be known.
But obtaining this from length frequency data is
not feasible.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Dr. Etim (Institute of Oceanography, University
of Calabar, Nigeria) is sponsored by the Alexander
von Humboldt (AvH) Foundation, Bonn during his
research tenure at the Alfred Wegener Institute
(AWl). Thanks are extended to AvH Foundation
for sponsorship, AWl for support, Mr Ernerst
Ayegbeku for help in field sampling and laboratory
measurements, and Dr. Edak Umoh for supervising
the cartographic work.
REFERENCES
BEVERTON, R.J.H. and S.J. HOLT, 1956. A review of methods for estimating mortality rates in fish populations, with special
references to sources of bias in catch sampling. Rapp. P.-V. R~un. Cons. Int. Explor. Mer. 140: 67-83.
BEVERTON, R.J.H. and S.J. HOLT, 1986. A manual of methods for fish stock assessment. Part 2. Tables of yields functions.
FAO Fish Technic. Pap. 38 Rev. 1: 67.
BERTI, R., L. CHELAZZI, I. COLOMBINI and A. ERCOLINI, 1992. Direction finding ability in a mudskipper from the delta of the Tana
River (Kenya) .Trop. Zool. 5: 219-228.
BERTI, R., L. CHELAZZI, I. COLOMBINI and A. ERGOLINI, 1994. Directional orientation in Kenyan populations o1 Periophthalmus
sobrinusEggert: Experimentalanalysis of the operating mechanisms. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol. 181: 135-141.
48
ETIM, BREY and ARN'rZ
BREY, T., M. SORIANO and D. PAULY, 1988. Electronic length frequency analysis. A revised and expanded users guide to ELEFAN O, 1
and 2 (2nd edition.) Bet. Inst. Meereskunde (Kiel), 1-31.
CLAYTON, D.A., 1993. Mudskippers. In: A.D. Ansel, R.N. Gibson and M. Barnes, Eds., Oceanography and Marine Ecology - An
Annual Review. 31. UCL Press London, p. 507-577.
COLOMBINI, I., A. BERTI, A. ERCOLINI, L. NOCITA. and L. CHELAZZI, 1995. Environmental factors influencing the zonation and activity
patterns of a population of Periophtha/mussobrinus Eggert in a Kenyan mangrove. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 190:135-149.
ETIM, L., 1993. Comparison of condition indices and their seasonal variation in the freshwater clam Egeria radiata (Lamarck) (Tellinacea:
Donacidae) from the Cross River, Nigeria. Aquacult. Fish. Managem. 24: 603-612.
ETIM, L and T. BREY, 1994. Growth, productivity and significance for fishery of the bivalve Egeria radiata (Donacidae) in the Cross River,
Nigeria. Arch. Fish Mar. Res. 42: 63-75.
ETIM, L., B.U. UWE-BASSEY and T. BREY, 1994 Population dynamics of the West African croaker Pseudoto/ithus e/ongatus in
the Cross River estuary, Nigeria. Sci. Mar. 58: 315-321.
GAYANILO Jr, F,C., M. SORIANO and D. PAULY, 1989. A draft guide to the Complete ELEFAN International Centre For Living
Aquatic Resource Management (ICLARM). Manila, Philippines, 1-70,
IKEBE, Y and T. Oishi, 1992. Diurnal change of behaviour pattern in the Chinese mudskipper Periophtha/muscantonensis(Abstract only),
Zool. Sci., 9:1296.
LOW, W.P., S.F. CHEW and Y. KIP, 1992. Difference in electrophoretic patterns of lactate dehydrogenases from the gills, hearts
and muscles of three mudskippers. J. Fish Biol. 40: 975-977.
MOREAU, J., C. BAMBINO and D. PAULY 1986. Indices of overall fish growth performances of 100 Ti/apia (Cichlidae) populations,
In: J. L. Maclean, L. B. Dizon and L. V. Hosillos, Eds., First Asian Fisheries Forum, Manila, Asian Fisheries Society, p. 201- 206.
PAULY, D., 1986. On improving the operation and use of ELEFAN programs. Part 1. Improving the estimation of L-infinity. Fishbyte
4: 18-20.
PAULY, D. and G. GASCHUTZ, 1979. A simple method for fitting oscillating length data, with a program for pocket calculators. ICESCM
1979/24. Demersal Fish Committee.
PAULY, D., 1980. On the interrelationships between natural mortality, growth parameters and mean environmental temperatures
in 175 fish stocks. J, Cons. Int. Explor. Met. 39:175 -192.
PAULY, D., 1983. Length-converted catch curves. A powerful tool for fisheries research in the tropics (Part 1). ICLARM Fishbyte 1: 9-13.
PAULY, D., 1987, A review of the system for analysis of length data in fish and invertebrates. In: D. Pauly and G.R. Morgan, Eds., Length
based methods in fisheries research. ICLARM Conf. Proc. ICLARM, Manila 13: 7-34.
PAULY, D and J.L. MUNRO, 1984. Once more on the growth comparison in fish and invertebrates. Fishbyte 2: 17-19.
PRESS, W.H., B.P. FLANNERY, S.A. TEUKOLSKY and W.T. VEI-rERLING, 1986. Numerical recipes: The art of scientific computing.
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
SOMERS, I.F., 1988. On seasonally oscillation growth function. Fishbyte 6:8-11.
60NI, V.C. and B. GEORGE, 1986. Age determination and length-weight relationship in the mudskipper Bo/eophtha/musdentatus. Indian
J. Fish., 33: 321-324.
SPONDER, D.L. and G.V. LAUDER, 1981. Terrestrial feeding in the mudskipper Periophtha/mus (Pisces: Teleostei). A cineradiographic
Analysis. J. Zool,, 193: 517-530.
SPRUGEL, D.G., 1983. Correcting for bias in log-transformed allometric equations. Ecology 64: 209-210,
SYSTAT, 1992. Statistics. Version 5.2 Edition. Systat Inc., Evanston, IL.
TAYLOR, C.C., 1960. Temperature, growth and mortality - the Pacific cockle. J. Cons. Int. Explor. Mer 26:117-124.
VAKILY, J.M,, 1992. Determination and comparison of growth in bivalves with emphasis on the tropics and Thailand. ICLARM
Tech. Rep., 36: 1-125.
VON BERTALANFFY,L., 1938. A quantitative theory of organic growth. Hum. Biol. 10: 181-213.
WETHERAL, J,A,, 1986. A new method for estimating growth and mortality parameters from length-frequency data. ICLARM Fishbyte
4: 12-14.
Address of the authors:
Alfred Wegener Institute for Polar and Marine Research, Postfach 120161, D-27515 Bremerhaven, Germany.